Recent theoretical research on tensor gauge theories led to the discovery of an exotic type of quasiparticles, dubbed fractons, that obey both charge and dipole conservation. Here we describe physical implementation of dipole conservation laws in rea
listic systems. We show that fractons find a natural realization in hole-doped antiferromagnets. There, individual holes are largely immobile, while dipolar hole pairs move with ease. First, we demonstrate a broad parametric regime of fracton behavior in hole-doped two-dimensional Ising antiferromagnets viable through five orders in perturbation theory. We then specialize to the case of holes confined to one dimension in an otherwise two-dimensional antiferromagnetic background, which can be realized via the application of external fields in experiments, and prove ideal fracton behavior. We explicitly map the model onto a fracton Hamiltonian featuring conservation of dipole moment. Manifestations of fractonicity in these systems include gravitational clustering of holes. We also discuss diagnostics of fracton behavior, which we argue is borne out in existing experimental results.
The Lieb-Schultz-Mattis (LSM) theorem implies that gapped phases of matter must satisfy non-trivial conditions on their low-energy properties when a combination of lattice translation and $U(1)$ symmetry are imposed. We describe a framework to charac
terize the action of symmetry on fractons and other sub-dimensional fractional excitations, and use this together with the LSM theorem to establish that X-cube fracton order can occur only at integer or half-odd-integer filling. Using explicit parton constructions, we demonstrate that odd
Recent work has shown that two seemingly different physical mechanisms, namely fracton behavior and confinement, can give rise to non-ergodicity in one-dimensional quantum many-body systems. In this work, we demonstrate an intrinsic link between thes
e two mechanisms by studying the dynamics of one-dimensional confining theories, such as a U(1) gauge theory and a quantum Ising model. We show that, within certain parameter regimes, these models exhibit effective fracton dynamics, characterized by immobility of stable single-particle excitations and free motion of dipolar bound states. By perturbatively integrating out the linearly confining field, we obtain an effective fracton Hamiltonian for the confined charges which exhibits conservation of dipole moment. We discuss an intuitive understanding of these results in terms of the motion of the confining strings, leading to potential extensions to higher dimensions. We thereby interpret recent observations of nonthermal eigenstates and glassy dynamics in confining theories in terms of corresponding results in the fracton literature.
We design a set of classical macroscopic electric circuits in which charge exhibits the mobility restrictions of fracton quasiparticles. The crucial ingredient in these circuits is a transformer, which induces currents between pairs of adjacent wires
. For an appropriately designed geometry, this induction serves to enforce conservation of dipole moment. We show that a network of capacitors connected via ideal transformers will forever remember the dipole moment of its initial charge configuration. Relaxation of the dipole moment in realistic systems can only occur via flux leakage in the transformers, which will lead to violations of fracton physics at the longest times. We propose a concrete diagnostic for these fractolectric circuits in the form of their characteristic equilibrium charge configurations, which we verify using simple circuit simulation software. These circuits not only provide an experimental testing ground for fracton physics, but also serve as DC filters. We outline extensions of these ideas to circuits featuring other types of higher moment conservation laws, as well as to higher-dimensional circuits which act as fracton current-ice. While our focus is on classical circuits, we discuss how these ideas can be straightforwardly extended to realize quantized fractons in superconducting circuits.
We demonstrate several explicit duality mappings between elasticity of two-dimensional crystals and fracton tensor gauge theories, expanding on recent works by two of the present authors. We begin by dualizing the quantum elasticity theory of an ordi
nary commensurate crystal, which maps directly onto a fracton tensor gauge theory, in a natural tensor analogue of the conventional particle-vortex duality transformation of a superfluid. The transverse and longitudinal phonons of a crystal map onto the two gapless gauge modes of the tensor gauge theory, while the topological lattice defects map onto the gauge charges, with disclinations corresponding to isolated fractons and dislocations corresponding to dipoles of fractons. We use the classical limit of this duality to make new predictions for the finite-temperature phase diagram of fracton models, and provide a simpler derivation of the Halperin-Nelson-Young theory of thermal melting of two-dimensional solids. We extend this duality to incorporate bosonic statistics, which is necessary for a description of the quantum melting transitions. We thereby derive a hybrid vector-tensor gauge theory which describes a supersolid phase, hosting both crystalline and superfluid orders. The structure of this gauge theory puts constraints on the quantum phase diagram of bosons, and also leads to the concept of symmetry enriched fracton order. We formulate the extension of these dualities to systems breaking time-reversal symmetry. We also discuss the broader implications of these dualities, such as a possible connection between fracton phases and the study of interacting topological crystalline insulators.
Fractons are a type of emergent quasiparticle which cannot move freely in isolation, but can easily move in bound pairs. Similar phenomenology is found in boson-affected hopping models, encountered in the study of polaron systems and hole-doped Ising
antiferromagnets, in which motion of a particle requires the creation or absorption of bosonic excitations. We show that boson-affected hopping models can provide a natural realization of fractons, either approximately or exactly, depending on the details of the system. We first consider a generic one-dimensional boson-affected hopping model, in which we show that single particles move only at sixth order in perturbation theory, while motion of bound states occurs at second order, allowing for a broad parameter regime exhibiting approximate fracton phenomenology. We explicitly map the model onto a fracton Hamiltonian featuring conservation of dipole moment via integrating out the mediating bosons. We then consider a special type of boson-affected hopping models with mutual hard-core repulsion between particles and bosons, accessible in hole-doped mixed-dimensional Ising antiferromagnets, in which the hole motion is one dimensional in an otherwise two-dimensional antiferromagnetic background. We show that this system, which is within the current reach of ultracold-atom experiments, exhibits perfect fracton behavior to all orders in perturbation theory, thereby enabling the experimental study of dipole-conserving field theories. We further discuss diagnostic signatures of fractonic behavior in these systems. In studying these models, we also identify simple effective one-dimensional microscopic Hamiltonians featuring perfect fractonic behavior, paving the way to future studies on fracton physics in lower dimensions.
Starting from a state of low quantum entanglement, local unitary time evolution increases the entanglement of a quantum many-body system. In contrast, local projective measurements disentangle degrees of freedom and decrease entanglement. We study th
e interplay of these competing tendencies by considering time evolution combining both unitary and projective dynamics. We begin by constructing a toy model of Bell pair dynamics which demonstrates that measurements can keep a system in a state of low (i.e. area law) entanglement, in contrast with the volume law entanglement produced by generic pure unitary time evolution. While the simplest Bell pair model has area law entanglement for any measurement rate, as seen in certain non-interacting systems, we show that more generic models of entanglement can feature an area-to-volume law transition at a critical value of the measurement rate, in agreement with recent numerical investigations. As a concrete example of these ideas, we analytically investigate Clifford evolution in qubit systems which can exhibit an entanglement transition. We are able to identify stabilizer size distributions characterizing the area law, volume law and critical fixed points. We also discuss Floquet random circuits, where the answers depend on the order of limits - one order of limits yields area law entanglement for any non-zero measurement rate, whereas a different order of limits allows for an area law - volume law transition. Finally, we provide a rigorous argument that a system subjected to projective measurements can only exhibit a volume law entanglement entropy if it also features a subleading correction term, which provides a universal signature of projective dynamics in the high-entanglement phase. Note: The results presented here supersede those of all previou
Motivated by the recently established duality between elasticity of crystals and a fracton tensor gauge theory, we combine it with boson-vortex duality, to explicitly account for bosonic statistics of the underlying atoms. We thereby derive a hybrid
vector-tensor gauge dual of a supersolid, which features both crystalline and superfluid order. The gauge dual describes a fracton state of matter with full dipole mobility endowed by the superfluid order, as governed by mutual axion electrodynamics between the fracton and vortex sectors of the theory, with an associated generalized Witten effect. Vortex condensation restores U(1) symmetry, confines dipoles to be subdimensional (recovering the dislocation glide constraint of a commensurate quantum crystal), and drives a phase transition between two distinct fracton phases. Meanwhile, condensation of elementary fracton dipoles and charges, respectively, provide a gauge dual description of the super-hexatic and ordinary superfluid. Consistent with conventional wisdom, in the absence of crystalline order, U(1)-symmetric phases are prohibited at zero temperature via a mechanism akin to deconfined quantum criticality.
A powerful mechanism for constructing gauge theories is to start from a theory with a global symmetry, then apply the gauge principle, which demands that this symmetry hold locally. For example, the global phase rotation of a system of conserved char
ges can be promoted to a local phase rotation by coupling to an ordinary U(1) vector gauge field. More recently, a class of particles has been studied featuring not only charge conservation, but also conservation of higher moments, such as dipole moment, which leads to severe restrictions on the mobility of charges. These particles, called fractons, are known to be intimately connected to symmetric tensor gauge fields. In this work, we show how to derive such tensor gauge theories by applying the gauge principle to a theory of ungauged fractons. We begin by formulating a field theory for ungauged fractons exhibiting global conservation of charge and dipole moment. We show that such fracton field theories have a characteristic non-Gaussian form, reflecting the fact that fractons intrinsically interact with each other even in the absence of a mediating gauge field. We then promote the global higher moment conservation laws to local ones, which requires the introduction of a symmetric tensor gauge field. Finally, we extend these arguments to other types of subdimensional particles besides fractons. This work offers a possible route to the formulation of non-abelian fracton theories.
Despite the seeming simplicity of the theory, calculating (and even defining) entanglement entropy for the Maxwell theory of a $U(1)$ gauge field in (3+1) dimensions has been the subject of controversy. It is generally accepted that the ground state
entanglement entropy for a region of linear size $L$ behaves as an area law with a subleading logarithm, $S = alpha L^2 -gamma log L$. While the logarithmic coefficient $gamma$ is believed to be universal, there has been disagreement about its precise value. After carefully accounting for subtle boundary corrections, multiple analyses in the high energy literature have converged on an answer related to the conformal trace anomaly, which is only sensitive to the local curvature of the partition. In contrast, a condensed matter treatment of the problem yielded a topological contribution which is not captured by the conformal field theory calculation. In this perspective piece, we review aspects of the various calculations and discuss the resolution of the discrepancy, emphasizing the important role played by charged states (the extended Hilbert space) in defining entanglement for a gauge theory. While the trace anomaly result is sufficient for a strictly pure gauge field, coupling the gauge field to dynamical charges of mass $m$ gives a topological contribution to $gamma$ which survives even in the $mrightarrowinfty$ limit. For many situations, the topological contribution from dynamical charges is physically meaningful and should be taken into account. We also comment on other common issues of entanglement in gauge theories, such as entanglement distillation, algebraic definitions of entanglement, and gauge-fixing procedures.
