Subscribe to the gold package and get unlimited access to Shamra Academy
Register a new userComments on: Echoes from the abyss: Evidence for Planck-scale structure at black hole horizons
123
0
0.0
(
0
)
Ask ChatGPT about the research
No Arabic abstract
Recently, Abedi, Dykaar and Afshordi claimed evidence for a repeating damped echo signal following the binary black hole merger gravitational-wave events recorded in the first observational period of the Advanced LIGO interferometers. We discuss the methods of data analysis and significance estimation leading to this claim, and identify several important shortcomings. We conclude that their analysis does not provide significant observational evidence for the existence of Planck-scale structure at black hole horizons, and suggest renewed analysis correcting for these shortcomings.
rate research
Read More
Gravitational wave echoes provide our most direct and surprising observational window into quantum nature of black holes. Three years ago, the first search for echoes from Planck-scale modifications of general relativity near black hole event horizons led to tentative evidence at false detection probability of 1% arXiv:1612.00266 . The study introduced a naive phenomenological model and used the public data release by the Advanced LIGO gravitational wave observatory for the first observing run O1 (GW150914, GW151226, and LVT151012, now GW151012). Here, we provide a status update on various observational searches for echoes by independent groups, and argue that they can all be consistent if echoes are most prominent at lower frequencies and/or in binary mergers of more extreme mass ratio. We also point out that the only reported detection of echoes (with $>4sigma$ confidence) at 1.0 second after the binary neutron star merger GW170817 arXiv:1803.10454 is coincident with the formation time of the black hole inferred from electromagnetic observations.
Recent detections of merging black holes allow observational tests of the nature of these objects. In some proposed models, non-trivial structure at or near the black hole horizon could lead to echo signals in gravitational wave data. Recently, Abedi et al. claimed tentative evidence for repeating damped echo signals following the gravitational-wave signals of the binary black hole merger events recorded in the first observational period of the Advanced LIGO interferometers. We reanalyse the same data, addressing some of the shortcomings of their method using more background data and a modified procedure. We find a reduced statistical significance for the claims of evidence for echoes, calculating increased p-values for the null hypothesis of echo-free noise. The reduced significance is entirely consistent with noise, and so we conclude that the analysis of Abedi et al. does not provide any observational evidence for the existence of Planck-scale structure at black hole horizons.
We consider a very simple model for gravitational wave echoes from black hole merger ringdowns which may arise from local Lorentz symmetry violations that modify graviton dispersion relations. If the corrections are sufficiently soft so they do not remove the horizon, the reflection of the infalling waves which trigger the echoes is very weak. As an example, we look at the dispersion relation of a test scalar field corrected by roton-like operators depending only on spatial momenta, in Gullstrand-Painleve coordinates. The near-horizon regions of a black hole do become reflective, but only very weakly. The resulting ``bounces of infalling waves can yield repetitive gravity wave emissions but their power is very small. This implies that to see any echoes from black holes we really need an egregious departure from either standard GR or effective field theory, or both. One possibility to realize such strong echoes is the recently proposed classical firewalls which replace black hole horizons with material shells surrounding timelike singularities.
We present the first numerical construction of the scalar Schwarzschild Green function in the time-domain, which reveals several universal features of wave propagation in black hole spacetimes. We demonstrate the trapping of energy near the photon sphere and confirm its exponential decay. The trapped wavefront propagates through caustics resulting in echoes that propagate to infinity. The arrival times and the decay rate of these caustic echoes are consistent with propagation along null geodesics and the large l-limit of quasinormal modes. We show that the four-fold singularity structure of the retarded Green function is due to the well-known action of a Hilbert transform on the trapped wavefront at caustics. A two-fold cycle is obtained for degenerate source-observer configurations along the caustic line, where the energy amplification increases with an inverse power of the scale of the source. Finally, we discuss the tail piece of the solution due to propagation within the light cone, up to and including null infinity, and argue that, even with ideal instruments, only a finite number of echoes can be observed. Putting these pieces together, we provide a heuristic expression that approximates the Green function with a few free parameters. Accurate calculations and approximations of the Green function are the most general way of solving for wave propagation in curved spacetimes and should be useful in a variety of studies such as the computation of the self-force on a particle.
Gravitational wave echoes from the black holes have been suggested as a crucial observable to probe the spacetime in the vicinity of the horizon. In particular, it was speculated that the echoes are closely connected with specific characteristics of the exotic compact objects, and moreover, possibly provide an access to the quantum nature of gravity. Recently, it was shown that the discontinuity in the black hole metric substantially modifies the asymptotical behavior of quasinormal frequencies. In the present study, we proceed further and argue that a discontinuity planted into the metric furnishes an alternative mechanism for the black hole echoes. Physically, the latter may correspond to an uneven matter distribution inside the surrounding halo. To demonstrate the results, we first numerically investigate the temporal evolution of the scalar perturbations around a black hole that possesses a nonsmooth effective potential. It is shown that the phenomenon persists even though the discontinuity can be located further away from the horizon with rather insignificant strength. Besides, we show that the echoes in the present model can be derived analytically based on the modified pole structure of the associated Green function. The asymptotical properties of the quasinormal mode spectrum and the echoes are found to be closely connected, as both features can be attributed to the same origin. In particular, the period of the echoes in the time domain $T$ is shown to be related to the asymptotic spacing between successive poles along the real axis in the frequency domain $Delta(Reomega)$, by a simple relation $limlimits_{Reomegato+infty}Delta(Reomega) = 2pi/T$. Moreover, we discuss possible distinguishment between different echo mechanisms. The potential astrophysical implications of the present findings are also addressed.
Log in to be able to interact and post comments
comments
Fetching comments
Sign in to be able to follow your search criteria
