No Arabic abstract
Solar flares - the most powerful explosions in the solar system - are also efficient particle accelerators, capable of energizing a large number of charged particles to relativistic speeds. A termination shock is often invoked in the standard model of solar flares as a possible driver for particle acceleration, yet its existence and role have remained controversial. We present observations of a solar flare termination shock and trace its morphology and dynamics using high-cadence radio imaging spectroscopy. We show that a disruption of the shock coincides with an abrupt reduction of the energetic electron population. The observed properties of the shock are well-reproduced by simulations. These results strongly suggest that a termination shock is responsible, at least in part, for accelerating energetic electrons in solar flares.
Solar flare termination shocks have been suggested as one of the promising drivers for particle acceleration in solar flares, yet observational evidence remains rare. By utilizing radio dynamic spectroscopic imaging of decimetric stochastic spike bursts in an eruptive flare, Chen et al. found that the bursts form a dynamic surface-like feature located at the ending points of fast plasma downflows above the looptop, interpreted as a flare termination shock. One piece of observational evidence that strongly supports the termination shock interpretation is the occasional split of the emission band into two finer lanes in frequency, similar to the split-band feature seen in fast-coronal-shock-driven type II radio bursts. Here we perform spatially, spectrally, and temporally resolved analysis of the split-band feature of the flare termination shock event. We find that the ensemble of the radio centroids from the two split-band lanes each outlines a nearly co-spatial surface. The high-frequency lane is located slightly below its low frequency counterpart by ~0.8 Mm, which strongly supports the shock upstream-downstream interpretation. Under this scenario, the density compression ratio across the shock front can be inferred from the frequency split, which implies a shock with a Mach number of up to 2.0. Further, the spatiotemporal evolution of the density compression along the shock front agrees favorably with results from magnetohydrodynamics simulations. We conclude that the detailed variations of the shock compression ratio may be due to the impact of dynamic plasma structures in the reconnection outflows, which results in distortion of the shock front.
A common feature of electromagnetic emission from solar flares is the presence of intensity pulsations that vary as a function of time. Known as quasi-periodic pulsations (QPPs), these variations in flux appear to include periodic components and characteristic time-scales. Here, we analyse a GOES M3.7 class flare exhibiting pronounced QPPs across a broad band of wavelengths using imaging and time-series analysis. We identify QPPs in the timeseries of X-ray, low frequency radio and EUV wavelengths using wavelet analysis, and localise the region of the flare site from which the QPPs originate via X-ray and EUV imaging. It was found that the pulsations within the 171 .A, 1600 .A, soft X-ray (SXR), and hard X-ray (HXR) light curves yielded similar periods of $sim$122 s, $sim$131s, $sim$123 s, and $sim$137 s, respectively, indicating a common progenitor. The low frequency radio emission at 2.5 MHz contained a longer period of $sim$231 s. Imaging analysis indicates that the location of the X-ray and EUV pulsations originates from a HXR footpoint linked to a system of nearby open magnetic field lines. Our results suggest that intermittent particle acceleration, likely due to bursty magnetic reconnection, is responsible for the QPPs. The precipitating electrons accelerated towards the chromosphere produce the X-ray and EUV pulsations, while the escaping electrons result in low frequency radio pulses in the form of type III radio bursts. The modulation of the reconnection process, resulting in episodic particle acceleration, explains the presence of these QPPs across the entire spatial range of flaring emission.
We use 2D particle-in-cell (PIC) plasma simulations to study electron acceleration by electron temperature anisotropy instabilities, assuming magnetic fields ($B$), electron densities ($n_e$) and temperatures ($T_e$) typical of the top of contracting magnetic loops in solar flares. We focus on the long-term effect of $T_{e,perp} > T_{e,parallel}$ instabilities by driving the anisotropy growth during the whole simulation time ($T_{e,perp}$ and $T_{e,parallel}$ are the temperatures perpendicular and parallel to the field). This is achieved by imposing a shear velocity, which amplifies the field due to magnetic flux freezing, making $T_{e,perp} > T_{e,parallel}$ due to electron magnetic moment conservation. We use the initial conditions: $T_e sim 52$ MK, and $B$ and $n_e$ such that the ratio between the electron cyclotron and plasma frequencies $omega_{ce}/omega_{pe}=0.53$. When the anisotropy becomes large enough, oblique, quasi-electrostatic (OQES) modes grow, efficiently scattering the electrons and limiting their anisotropy. After that, when $B$ has grown by a factor $sim 2-3$ (corresponding to $omega_{ce}/omega_{pe}sim 1.2-1.5$), the unstable modes become dominated by parallel, electromagnetic z (PEMZ) modes. In contrast to the OQES dominated regime, the scattering by PEMZ modes is highly inelastic, producing significant electron acceleration. When the field has grown by a final factor $sim 4$, the electron energy spectrum shows a nonthermal tail that resembles a power-law of index $sim$ 2.9, plus a high-energy bump reaching $sim 300$ keV. Our results suggest a critical role played by $omega_{ce}/omega_{pe}$ and $T_e$ in determining the efficiency of electron acceleration by temperature anisotropy instabilities in solar flares.
Solar flare termination shocks have been suggested as one of the viable mechanisms for accelerating electrons and ions to high energies. Observational evidence of such shocks, however, remains rare. Using radio dynamic spectroscopic imaging of a long-duration C1.9 flare obtained by the Karl G. Jansky Very Large Array (VLA), Chen et al. (2015) suggested that a type of coherent radio bursts, referred to as stochastic spike bursts, were radio signatures of nonthermal electrons interacting with myriad density fluctuations at the front of a flare termination shock. Here we report another stochastic spike burst event recorded during the extended energy release phase of a long-duration M8.4-class eruptive flare on 2012 March 10. VLA radio spectroscopic imaging of the spikes in 1.0--1.6 GHz shows that similar to the case of Chen et al. (2015), the burst centroids form an extended, ~10-long structure in the corona. By combining extreme-ultraviolet imaging observations of the flare from two vantage points with hard X-ray and ultraviolet observations of the flare ribbon brightenings, we reconstruct the flare arcade in three dimensions. The results show that the spike source is located at ~60 Mm above the flare arcade, where a diffuse supra-arcade fan and multitudes of plasma downflows are present. Although the flare arcade and ribbons seen during the impulsive phase do not allow us to clearly understand how the observed spike source location is connected to the flare geometry, the cooling flare arcade observed two hours later suggests that the spikes are located in the above-the-loop-top region, where a termination shock presumably forms.
Solar energetic particles acceleration by a shock wave accompanying a coronal mass ejection (CME) is studied. The description of the accelerated particle spectrum evolution is based on the numerical calculation of the diffusive transport equation with a set of realistic parameters. The relation between the CME and the shock speeds, which depend on the initial CME radius, is determined. Depending on the initial CME radius, its speed, and the magnetic energy of the scattering Alfven waves, the accelerated particle spectrum is established during 10-60 minutes from the beginning of CME motion. The maximum energies of particles reach 0.1-10 GeV. The CME radii of 3-5 $R_odot$ and the shock radii of 5-10 $R_odot$ agree with observations. The calculated particle spectra agree with the observed ones in events registered by ground-based detectors if the turbulence spectrum in the solar corona significantly differs from the Kolmogorov one.