Multiplicity per rapidity in Carruthers and hadron resonance gas approaches

The multiplicity per rapidity of the well-identified particles $pi^{-}$, $pi^{+}$, $k^{-}$, $k^{+}$, $bar{p}$, $p$, and $p-bar{p}$ measured in different high-energy experiments, at energies ranging from $6.3$ to $5500~$GeV, are successfully compared with the Cosmic Ray Monte Carlo (CRMC) event generator. For these rapidity distributions, we introduce a theoretical approach based on fluctuations and correlations (Carruthers) and another one based on statistical thermal assumptions (hadron resonance gas model). Both approaches are fitted to the two sets of results deduced from experiments and simulations. We found that the Carruthers approach reproduces well the full range of multiplicity per rapidity for all produced particles, at the various energies, while the HRG approach fairly describes the results within a narrower rapidity-range. While the Carruthers approach seems to match well with the Gaussian normal distribution, ingredients such as flow and interactions should be first incorporated in the HRG approach.