اشترك بالحزمة الذهبية واحصل على وصول غير محدود شمرا أكاديميا
تسجيل مستخدم جديدMissing Data and Prediction
71
0
0.0
(
0
)
نشر من قبل
Sarah Fletcher Mercaldo
تاريخ النشر
2017
مجال البحث
الاحصاء الرياضي
والبحث باللغة
English
اسأل ChatGPT حول البحث
ﻻ يوجد ملخص باللغة العربية
Missing data are a common problem for both the construction and implementation of a prediction algorithm. Pattern mixture kernel submodels (PMKS) - a series of submodels for every missing data pattern that are fit using only data from that pattern - are a computationally efficient remedy for both stages. Here we show that PMKS yield the most predictive algorithm among all standard missing data strategies. Specifically, we show that the expected loss of a forecasting algorithm is minimized when each pattern-specific loss is minimized. Simulations and a re-analysis of the SUPPORT study confirms that PMKS generally outperforms zero-imputation, mean-imputation, complete-case analysis, complete-case submodels, and even multiple imputation (MI). The degree of improvement is highly dependent on the missingness mechanism and the effect size of missing predictors. When the data are Missing at Random (MAR) MI can yield comparable forecasting performance but generally requires a larger computational cost. We see that predictions from the PMKS are equivalent to the limiting predictions for a MI procedure that uses a mean model dependent on missingness indicators (the MIMI model). Consequently, the MIMI model can be used to assess the MAR assumption in practice. The focus of this paper is on out-of-sample prediction behavior, implications for model inference are only briefly explored.
قيم البحث
اقرأ أيضاً
Classical semiparametric inference with missing outcome data is not robust to contamination of the observed data and a single observation can have arbitrarily large influence on estimation of a parameter of interest. This sensitivity is exacerbated w
hen inverse probability weighting methods are used, which may overweight contaminated observations. We introduce inverse probability weighted, double robust and outcome regression estimators of location and scale parameters, which are robust to contamination in the sense that their influence function is bounded. We give asymptotic properties and study finite sample behaviour. Our simulated experiments show that contamination can be more serious a threat to the quality of inference than model misspecification. An interesting aspect of our results is that the auxiliary outcome model used to adjust for ignorable missingness by some of the estimators, is also useful to protect against contamination. We also illustrate through a case study how both adjustment to ignorable missingness and protection against contamination are achieved through weighting schemes, which can be contrasted to gain further insights.
In the field of materials science and engineering, statistical analysis and machine learning techniques have recently been used to predict multiple material properties from an experimental design. These material properties correspond to response vari
ables in the multivariate regression model. This study conducts a penalized maximum likelihood procedure to estimate model parameters, including the regression coefficients and covariance matrix of response variables. In particular, we employ $l_1$-regularization to achieve a sparse estimation of regression coefficients and the inverse covariance matrix of response variables. In some cases, there may be a relatively large number of missing values in response variables, owing to the difficulty in collecting data on material properties. A method to improve prediction accuracy under the situation with missing values incorporates a correlation structure among the response variables into the statistical model. The expectation and maximization algorithm is constructed, which enables application to a data set with missing values in the responses. We apply our proposed procedure to real data consisting of 22 material properties.
We develop a representation of Gaussian distributed sparsely sampled longitudinal data whereby the data for each subject are mapped to a multivariate Gaussian distribution; this map is entirely data-driven. The proposed method utilizes functional pri
ncipal component analysis and is nonparametric, assuming no prior knowledge of the covariance or mean structure of the longitudinal data. This approach naturally connects with a deeper investigation of the behavior of the functional principal component scores obtained for longitudinal data, as the number of observations per subject increases from sparse to dense. We show how this is reflected in the shrinkage of the distribution of the conditional scores given noisy longitudinal observations towards a point mass located at the true but unobservable FPCs. Mapping each subjects sparse observations to the corresponding conditional score distribution leads to useful visualizations and representations of sparse longitudinal data. Asymptotic rates of convergence as sample size increases are obtained for the 2-Wasserstein metric between the true and estimated conditional score distributions, both for a $K$-truncated functional principal component representation as well as for the case when $K=K(n)$ diverges with sample size $ntoinfty$. We apply these ideas to construct predictive distributions aimed at predicting outcomes given sparse longitudinal data.
In electronic health records (EHRs), latent subgroups of patients may exhibit distinctive patterning in their longitudinal health trajectories. For such data, growth mixture models (GMMs) enable classifying patients into different latent classes base
d on individual trajectories and hypothesized risk factors. However, the application of GMMs is hindered by the special missing data problem in EHRs, which manifests two patient-led missing data processes: the visit process and the response process for an EHR variable conditional on a patient visiting the clinic. If either process is associated with the process generating the longitudinal outcomes, then valid inferences require accounting for a nonignorable missing data mechanism. We propose a Bayesian shared parameter model that links GMMs of multiple longitudinal health outcomes, the visit process, and the response process of each outcome given a visit using a discrete latent class variable. Our focus is on multiple longitudinal health outcomes for which there can be a clinically prescribed visit schedule. We demonstrate our model in EHR measurements on early childhood weight and height z-scores. Using data simulations, we illustrate the statistical properties of our method with respect to subgroup-specific or marginal inferences. We built the R package EHRMiss for model fitting, selection, and checking.
Missing data is a common problem which has consistently plagued statisticians and applied analytical researchers. While replacement methods like mean-based or hot deck imputation have been well researched, emerging imputation techniques enabled throu
gh improved computational resources have had limited formal assessment. This study formally considers five more recently developed imputation methods: Amelia, Mice, mi, Hmisc and missForest - compares their performances using RMSE against actual values and against the well-established mean-based replacement approach. The RMSE measure was consolidated by method using a ranking approach. Our results indicate that the missForest algorithm performed best and the mi algorithm performed worst.
سجل دخول لتتمكن من نشر تعليقات
التعليقات
جاري جلب التعليقات
سجل دخول لتتمكن من متابعة معايير البحث التي قمت باختيارها
