Incommensurate spiral order is a common occurrence in frustrated magnetic insulators. Typically, all magnetic moments rotate uniformly, through the same wavevector. However the honeycomb iridates family Li2IrO3 shows an incommensurate order where spi
rals on neighboring sublattices are counter-rotating, giving each moment a different local environment. Theoretically describing its spin dynamics has remained a challenge: the Kitaev interactions proposed to stabilize this state, which arise from strong spin-orbit effects, induce magnon umklapp scattering processes in spin-wave theory. Here we propose an approach via a (Klein) duality transformation into a conventional spiral of a frustrated Heisenberg model, allowing a direct derivation of the dynamical structure factor. We analyze both Kitaev and Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya based models, both of which can stabilize counterrotating spirals, but with different spin dynamics, and we propose experimental tests to identify the origin of counterrotation.
A family of insulating iridates with chemical formula Li$_2$IrO$_3$ has recently been discovered, featuring three distinct crystal structures $alpha,beta,gamma$ (honeycomb, hyperhoneycomb, stripyhoneycomb). Measurements on the three-dimensional polyt
ypes, $beta$- and $gamma$-Li$_2$IrO$_3$, found that they magnetically order into remarkably similar spiral phases, exhibiting a non-coplanar counter-rotating spiral magnetic order with equivalent q=0.57 wavevectors. We examine magnetic Hamiltonians for this family and show that the same triplet of nearest-neighbor Kitaev-Heisenberg-Ising (KJI) interactions reproduces this spiral order on both $beta,gamma$-Li$_2$IrO$_3$ structures. We analyze the origin of this phenomenon by studying the model on a 1D zigzag chain, a structural unit common to the three polytypes. The zigzag-chain solution transparently shows how the Kitaev interaction stabilizes the counter-rotating spiral, which is shown to persist on restoring the inter-chain coupling. Our minimal model makes a concrete prediction for the magnetic order in $alpha$-Li$_2$IrO$_3$.
