Model of the Weak Reset Process in HfOx Resistive Memory for Deep Learning Frameworks

The implementation of current deep learning training algorithms is power-hungry, owing to data transfer between memory and logic units. Oxide-based RRAMs are outstanding candidates to implement in-memory computing, which is less power-intensive. Their weak RESET regime, is particularly attractive for learning, as it allows tuning the resistance of the devices with remarkable endurance. However, the resistive change behavior in this regime suffers many fluctuations and is particularly challenging to model, especially in a way compatible with tools used for simulating deep learning. In this work, we present a model of the weak RESET process in hafnium oxide RRAM and integrate this model within the PyTorch deep learning framework. Validated on experiments on a hybrid CMOS/RRAM technology, our model reproduces both the noisy progressive behavior and the device-to-device (D2D) variability. We use this tool to train Binarized Neural Networks for the MNIST handwritten digit recognition task and the CIFAR-10 object classification task. We simulate our model with and without various aspects of device imperfections to understand their impact on the training process and identify that the D2D variability is the most detrimental aspect. The framework can be used in the same manner for other types of memories to identify the device imperfections that cause the most degradation, which can, in turn, be used to optimize the devices to reduce the impact of these imperfections.

Data assimilation for chaotic dynamics

Chaos is ubiquitous in physical systems. The associated sensitivity to initial conditions is a significant obstacle in forecasting the weather and other geophysical fluid flows. Data assimilation is the process whereby the uncertainty in initial conditions is reduced by the astute combination of model predictions and real-time data. This chapter reviews recent findings from investigations on the impact of chaos on data assimilation methods: for the Kalman filter and smoother in linear systems, analytic results are derived; for their ensemble-bas

Implementation of Ternary Weights with Resistive RAM Using a Single Sense Operation per Synapse

The design of systems implementing low precision neural networks with emerging memories such as resistive random access memory (RRAM) is a significant lead for reducing the energy consumption of artificial intelligence. To achieve maximum energy efficiency in such systems, logic and memory should be integrated as tightly as possible. In this work, we focus on the case of ternary neural networks, where synaptic weights assume ternary values. We propose a two-transistor/two-resistor memory architecture employing a precharge sense amplifier, where the weight value can be extracted in a single sense operation. Based on experimental measurements on a hybrid 130 nm CMOS/RRAM chip featuring this sense amplifier, we show that this technique is particularly appropriate at low supply voltage, and that it is resilient to process, voltage, and temperature variations. We characterize the bit error rate in our scheme. We show based on neural network simulation on the CIFAR-10 image recognition task that the use of ternary neural networks significantly increases neural network performance, with regards to binary ones, which are often preferred for inference hardware. We finally evidence that the neural network is immune to the type of bit errors observed in our scheme, which can therefore be used without error correction.

Embracing the Unreliability of Memory Devices for Neuromorphic Computing

The emergence of resistive non-volatile memories opens the way to highly energy-efficient computation near- or in-memory. However, this type of computation is not compatible with conventional ECC, and has to deal with device unreliability. Inspired by the architecture of animal brains, we present a manufactured differential hybrid CMOS/RRAM memory architecture suitable for neural network implementation that functions without formal ECC. We also show that using low-energy but error-prone programming conditions only slightly reduces network accuracy.

In-Memory Resistive RAM Implementation of Binarized Neural Networks for Medical Applications

The advent of deep learning has considerably accelerated machine learning development. The deployment of deep neural networks at the edge is however limited by their high memory and energy consumption requirements. With new memory technology available, emerging Binarized Neural Networks (BNNs) are promising to reduce the energy impact of the forthcoming machine learning hardware generation, enabling machine learning on the edge devices and avoiding data transfer over the network. In this work, after presenting our implementation employing a hybrid CMOS - hafnium oxide resistive memory technology, we suggest strategies to apply BNNs to biomedical signals such as electrocardiography and electroencephalography, keeping accuracy level and reducing memory requirements. We investigate the memory-accuracy trade-off when binarizing whole network and binarizing solely the classifier part. We also discuss how these results translate to the edge-oriented Mobilenet~V1 neural network on the Imagenet task. The final goal of this research is to enable smart autonomous healthcare devices.

Low Power In-Memory Implementation of Ternary Neural Networks with Resistive RAM-Based Synapse

The design of systems implementing low precision neural networks with emerging memories such as resistive random access memory (RRAM) is a major lead for reducing the energy consumption of artificial intelligence (AI). Multiple works have for example proposed in-memory architectures to implement low power binarized neural networks. These simple neural networks, where synaptic weights and neuronal activations assume binary values, can indeed approach state-of-the-art performance on vision tasks. In this work, we revisit one of these architectures where synapses are implemented in a differential fashion to reduce bit errors, and synaptic weights are read using precharge sense amplifiers. Based on experimental measurements on a hybrid 130 nm CMOS/RRAM chip and on circuit simulation, we show that the same memory array architecture can be used to implement ternary weights instead of binary weights, and that this technique is particularly appropriate if the sense amplifier is operated in near-threshold regime. We also show based on neural network simulation on the CIFAR-10 image recognition task that going from binary to ternary neural networks significantly increases neural network performance. These results highlight that AI circuits function may sometimes be revisited when operated in low power regimes.

Digital Biologically Plausible Implementation of Binarized Neural Networks with Differential Hafnium Oxide Resistive Memory Arrays

The brain performs intelligent tasks with extremely low energy consumption. This work takes inspiration from two strategies used by the brain to achieve this energy efficiency: the absence of separation between computing and memory functions, and the reliance on low precision computation. The emergence of resistive memory technologies indeed provides an opportunity to co-integrate tightly logic and memory in hardware. In parallel, the recently proposed concept of Binarized Neural Network, where multiplications are replaced by exclusive NOR (XNOR) logic gates, offers a way to implement artificial intelligence using very low precision computation. In this work, we therefore propose a strategy to implement low energy Binarized Neural Networks, which employs brain-inspired concepts, while retaining energy benefits from digital electronics. We design, fabricate and test a memory array, including periphery and sensing circuits, optimized for this in-memory computing scheme. Our circuit employs hafnium oxide resistive memory integrated in the back end of line of a 130 nanometer CMOS process, in a two transistors - two resistors cell, which allows performing the exclusive NOR operations of the neural network directly within the sense amplifiers. We show, based on extensive electrical measurements, that our design allows reducing the amount of bit errors on the synaptic weights, without the use of formal error correcting codes. We design a whole system using this memory array. We show on standard machine learning tasks (MNIST, CIFAR-10, ImageNet and an ECG task) that the system has an inherent resilience to bit errors. We evidence that its energy consumption is attractive compared to more standard approaches, and that it can use the memory devices in regimes where they exhibit particularly low programming energy and high endurance.

Stochastic Computing for Hardware Implementation of Binarized Neural Networks

Binarized Neural Networks, a recently discovered class of neural networks with minimal memory requirements and no reliance on multiplication, are a fantastic opportunity for the realization of compact and energy efficient inference hardware. However, such neural networks are generally not entirely binarized: their first layer remains with fixed point input. In this work, we propose a stochastic computing version of Binarized Neural Networks, where the input is also binarized. Simulations on the example of the Fashion-MNIST and CIFAR-10 datasets show that such networks can approach the performance of conventional Binarized Neural Networks. We evidence that the training procedure should be adapted for use with stochastic computing. Finally, the ASIC implementation of our scheme is investigated, in a system that closely associates logic and memory, implemented by Spin Torque Magnetoresistive Random Access Memory. This analysis shows that the stochastic computing approach can allow considerable savings with regards to conventional Binarized Neural networks in terms of area (62% area reduction on the Fashion-MNIST task). It can also allow important savings in terms of energy consumption, if we accept reasonable reduction of accuracy: for example a factor 2.1 can be saved, with the cost of 1.4% in Fashion-MNIST test accuracy. These results highlight the high potential of Binarized Neural Networks for hardware implementation, and that adapting them to hardware constrains can provide important benefits.

Outstanding Bit Error Tolerance of Resistive RAM-Based Binarized Neural Networks

Resistive random access memories (RRAM) are novel nonvolatile memory technologies, which can be embedded at the core of CMOS, and which could be ideal for the in-memory implementation of deep neural networks. A particularly exciting vision is using them for implementing Binarized Neural Networks (BNNs), a class of deep neural networks with a highly reduced memory footprint. The challenge of resistive memory, however, is that they are prone to device variation, which can lead to bit errors. In this work we show that BNNs can tolerate these bit errors to an outstanding level, through simulations of networks on the MNIST and CIFAR10 tasks. If a standard BNN is used, up to 10^-4 bit error rate can be tolerated with little impact on recognition performance on both MNIST and CIFAR10. We then show that by adapting the training procedure to the fact that the BNN will be operated on error-prone hardware, this tolerance can be extended to a bit error rate of 4x10^-2. The requirements for RRAM are therefore a lot less stringent for BNNs than more traditional applications. We show, based on experimental measurements on a RRAM HfO2 technology, that this result can allow reduce RRAM programming energy by a factor 30.

In-Memory and Error-Immune Differential RRAM Implementation of Binarized Deep Neural Networks

RRAM-based in-Memory Computing is an exciting road for implementing highly energy efficient neural networks. This vision is however challenged by RRAM variability, as the efficient implementation of in-memory computing does not allow error correction. In this work, we fabricated and tested a differential HfO2-based memory structure and its associated sense circuitry, which are ideal for in-memory computing. For the first time, we show that our approach achieves the same reliability benefits as error correction, but without any CMOS overhead. We show, also for the first time, that it can naturally implement Binarized Deep Neural Networks, a very recent development of Artificial Intelligence, with extreme energy efficiency, and that the system is fully satisfactory for image recognition applications. Finally, we evidence how the extra reliability provided by the differential memory allows programming the devices in low voltage conditions, where they feature high endurance of billions of cycles.