Optical-radio positional offsets for active galactic nuclei

Context. It will soon become possible to directly link the most accurate radio reference frame with the Gaia optical reference frame using many common extragalactic objects. It is important to know the level of coincidence between the radio and optical positions of compact active galactic nuclei (AGN). Aims. Using the best catalogues available at present, we investigate how many AGN with significantly large optical-radio positional offsets exist as well as the possible causes of these offsets. Methods. We performed a case study by finding optical counterparts to the International Celestial Reference Frame (ICRF2) radio sources in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) Data Release 9 (DR9). The ICRF2 catalogue was used as a reference because the radio positions determined by Very Long Baseline Interferometry (VLBI) observations are about two orders of magnitude more accurate than the optical positions. Results. We find 1297 objects in common for ICRF2 and SDSS DR9. Statistical analysis of the optical-radio differences verifies that the SDSS DR9 positions are accurate to ~55 mas in both coordinates, with no systematic offset with respect to ICRF2. We find 51 sources (~4% of the sample) for which the positional offset exceeds 170 mas (~3{sigma}). Astrophysical explanations must exist for most of these outliers. There are 3 known strong gravitational lenses among them. Dual AGN or recoiling supermassive black holes may also be possible. Conclusions. The most accurate Gaia-VLBI reference frame link will require a careful selection of a common set of objects by eliminating the outliers. On the other hand, the significant optical-radio positional non-coincidences may offer a new tool for finding e.g. gravitational lenses or dual AGN candidates. Detailed follow-up radio interferometric and optical spectroscopic observations are encouraged to investigate the outlier sources found in this study.

Radio-optical outlier quasars - a case study with ICRF2 and SDSS

With Gaia, it will become possible to directly link the radio and optical reference frames using a large number of common objects. For the most accurate radio-optical link, it is important to know the level of spatial coincidence between the quasars optical positions, and the radio positions determined by Very Long Baseline Interferometry (VLBI) observations. The outlier objects, for which the positions are significantly offset at the two different electromagnetic wavebands, may be of astrophysical interest as well. Here we present a case study to compare the radio positions of ~800 quasars common in the second realization of the International Celestial Reference Frame (ICRF2) and in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Data Release 7 (SDSS DR7) catalogue. Compared to the radio ICRF2, the SDSS provides two orders of magnitude less accurate astrometric data in the optical. However, its extensive sky coverage and faint magnitude limit allow us to directly relate the positions of a large sample of radio sources. This way we provide an independent check of the overall accuracy of the SDSS positions and confirm that the astrometric calibration of the latest Data Release 8 (DR8) is poorer than that of the DR7. We find over 20 sources for which the optical and radio brightness peaks are apparently not coincident at least at the 3-sigma level of SDSS DR7 positional accuracy, and briefly discuss the possible causes, including dual active galactic nuclei.