Subscribe to the gold package and get unlimited access to Shamra Academy
Register a new userThe O II Recombination Line Abundance Problem in Planetary Nebulae
122
0
0.0
(
0
)
Authors
D. R. Garnett
Ask ChatGPT about the research
No Arabic abstract
We present new observations of O II recombination lines in ten bright planetary nebulae, along with spatially-resolved measurements of O II and [O III] in the Ring nebula NGC 6720, to study the discrepancy between abundances derived from O II recombination lines and those derived from collisionally-excited [O III]. We see a large range in the difference between O II- and [O III] derived abundances, from no difference up to a factor six difference. The size of this discrepancy is anti-correlated with nebular surface brightness; compact, high-surface-brightness nebulae have the smallest discrepancies. O II levels that are populated mainly by dielectronic recombination give larger abundances than other levels. Finally, our long-slit observation of the Ring nebula shows that the O II emission peaks interior to the bright shell where [O III] and H-beta are strongest. Based on the observed correlations, we propose that the strong recombination line emission in planetary nebulae is a result of enhanced dielectronic recombination in hot gas in the nebular interior, perhaps driven by a hot stellar wind.
rate research
Read More
Recombination lines (RLs) of C II, N II, and O II in planetary nebulae (PNs) have been found to give abundances that are much larger in some cases than abundances from collisionally-excited forbidden lines (CELs). The origins of this abundance discrepancy are highly debated. We present new spectroscopic observations of O II and C II recombination lines for six planetary nebulae. With these data we compare the abundances derived from the optical recombination lines with those determined from collisionally-excited lines. Combining our new data with published results on RLs in other PNs, we examine the discrepancy in abundances derived from RLs and CELs. We find that there is a wide range in the measured abundance discrepancy Delta(O+2) = log O+2(RL) - log O+2(CEL), ranging from approximately 0.1 dex up to 1.4 dex. Most RLs yield similar abundances, with the notable exception of O II multiplet V15, known to arise primarily from dielectronic recombination, which gives abundances averaging 0.6 dex higher than other O II RLs. We compare Delta(O+2) against a variety of physical properties of the PNs to look for clues as to the mechanism responsible for the abundance discrepancy. The strongest correlations are found with the nebula diameter and the Balmer surface brightness. An inverse correlation of Delta(O+2) with nebular density is also seen. Similar results are found for carbon in comparing C II RL abundances with ultraviolet measurements of C III].
The iron depletion factors found in Galactic planetary nebulae (PNe) span over two orders of magnitude, suggesting that there are differences in the grain formation and destruction processes from object to object. We explore here the relation between the iron depletions, the infrared dust features, and the C/O abundance ratios in a sample of Galactic PNe. We find that those objects with C/O < 1 show a trend of increasing depletions for higher values of C/O, whereas PNe with C/O > 1 break the trend and cover all the range of depletions. Most of the PNe with C/O < 1 show silicate features, but several PNe with C-rich features have C/O < 1, probably reflecting the uncertainties associated with the derivation of C/O. PAHs are distributed over the entire range of iron depletions and C/O values.
We constrain the iron abundance in a sample of 33 low-ionization Galactic planetary nebulae (PNe) using [Fe III] lines and correcting for the contribution of higher ionization states with ionization correction factors (ICFs) that take into account uncertainties in the atomic data. We find very low iron abundances in all the objects, suggesting that more than 90% of their iron atoms are condensed onto dust grains. This number is based on the solar iron abundance and implies a lower limit on the dust-to-gas mass ratio, due solely to iron, of M_dust/M_gas>1.3x10^{-3} for our sample. The depletion factors of different PNe cover about two orders of magnitude, probably reflecting differences in the formation, growth, or destruction of their dust grains. However, we do not find any systematic difference between the gaseous iron abundances calculated for C-rich and O-rich PNe, suggesting similar iron depletion efficiencies in both environments. The iron abundances of our sample PNe are similar to those derived following the same procedure for a group of 10 Galactic H II regions. These high depletion factors argue for high depletion efficiencies of refractory elements onto dust grains both in molecular clouds and AGB stars, and low dust destruction efficiencies both in interstellar and circumstellar ionized gas.
[Abridged] Deep optical observations of the spectra of 12 Galactic planetary nebulae (PNe) and 3 Magellanic Cloud PNe were presented in Paper I by Tsamis et al. (2003b), who carried out an abundance analysis using the collisionally excited forbidden lines. Here, the relative intensities of faint optical recombination lines (ORLs) from ions of carbon, nitrogen and oxygen are analysed in order to derive the abundances of these ions relative to hydrogen. We define an abundance discrepancy factor (ADF) as the ratio of the abundance derived for a heavy element ion from its recombination lines to that derived for the same ion from its ultraviolet, optical or infrared collisionally excited lines (CELs). All of the PNe in our sample are found to have ADFs that exceed unity. There is no dependence of the magnitude of the ADF upon the excitation energy of the UV, optical or IR CEL transition used, indicating that classical nebular temperature fluctuations--i.e. in a chemically homogeneous medium--are not the cause of the observed abundance discrepancies. Instead, we conclude that the main cause of the discrepancy is enhanced ORL emission from cold ionized gas located in hydrogen-deficient clumps inside the main body of the nebulae. We have developed a new electron temperature diagnostic, based upon the relative intensities of the OII 4f-3d 4089A and 3p-3s 4649A recombination transitions. For six out of eight PNe for which both transitions are detected, we derive O2+ ORL electron temperatures of <300 K, very much less than the O2+ forbidden-line and Balmer jump temperatures derived for the same nebulae. These results provide direct observational evidence for the presence of H-deficient, cold plasma regions within the nebulae, consistent with gas cooled largely by infrared fine structure and recombination transitions.
We present deep high-resolution (R~15,000) and high-quality UVES optical spectrophotometry of nine planetary nebulae with dual-dust chemistry. We compute physical conditions from several diagnostics. Ionic abundances for a large number of ions of N, O, Ne, S, Cl, Ar, K, Fe and Kr are derived from collisionally excited lines. Elemental abundances are computed using state-of-the-art ionization correction factors. We derive accurate C/O ratios from optical recombination lines. We have re-analyzed additional high-quality spectra of 14 PNe from the literature following the same methodology. Comparison with asymptotic giant branch models reveals that about half of the total sample objects are consistent with being descendants of low-mass progenitor stars (M < 1.5 Msun). Given the observed N/O, C/O, and He/H ratios, we cannot discard that some of the objects come from more massive progenitor stars (M > 3--4 Msun) that have suffered a mild HBB. None of the objects seem to be a descendant of very massive progenitors. We propose that in most of the planetary nebulae studied here, the PAHs have been formed through the dissociation of the CO molecule. The hypothesis of a last thermal pulse that turns O-rich PNe into C-rich PNe is discarded, except in three objects, that show C/O > 1. We also discuss the possibility of a He pre-enrichment to explain the most He-enriched objects. We cannot discard other scenarios like extra mixing, stellar rotation or binary interactions to explain the chemical abundances behaviour observed in our sample.
Log in to be able to interact and post comments
comments
Fetching comments
Sign in to be able to follow your search criteria
