Subscribe to the gold package and get unlimited access to Shamra Academy
Register a new userEvidence against a supervoid causing the CMB Cold Spot
128
0
0.0
(
0
)
Authors
Ruari Mackenzie
Ask ChatGPT about the research
No Arabic abstract
We report the results of the 2dF-VST ATLAS Cold Spot galaxy redshift survey (2CSz) based on imaging from VST ATLAS and spectroscopy from 2dF AAOmega over the core of the CMB Cold Spot. We sparsely surveyed the inner 5$^{circ}$ radius of the Cold Spot to a limit of $i_{AB} le 19.2$, sampling $sim7000$ galaxies at $z<0.4$. We have found voids at $z=$ 0.14, 0.26 and 0.30 but they are interspersed with small over-densities and the scale of these voids is insufficient to explain the Cold Spot through the $Lambda$CDM ISW effect. Combining with previous data out to $zsim1$, we conclude that the CMB Cold Spot could not have been imprinted by a void confined to the inner core of the Cold Spot. Additionally we find that our control field GAMA G23 shows a similarity in its galaxy redshift distribution to the Cold Spot. Since the GAMA G23 line-of-sight shows no evidence of a CMB temperature decrement we conclude that the Cold Spot may have a primordial origin rather than being due to line-of-sight effects.
rate research
Read More
We use a WISE-2MASS-Pan-STARRS1 galaxy catalog to search for a supervoid in the direction of the Cosmic Microwave Background Cold Spot. We obtain photometric redshifts using our multicolor data set to create a tomographic map of the galaxy distribution. The radial density profile centred on the Cold Spot shows a large low density region, extending over 10s of degrees. Motivated by previous Cosmic Microwave Background results, we test for underdensities within two angular radii, $5^circ$, and $15^circ$. Our data, combined with an earlier measurement by Granett et al 2010, are consistent with a large $R_{rm void}=(192 pm 15)h^{-1} Mpc $ $(2sigma)$ supervoid with $delta simeq -0.13 pm 0.03$ centered at $z=0.22pm0.01$. Such a supervoid, constituting a $sim3.5 sigma$ fluctuation in the $Lambda CDM$ model, is a plausible cause for the Cold Spot.
Standard inflationary hot big bang cosmology predicts small fluctuations in the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) with isotropic Gaussian statistics. All measurements support the standard theory, except for a few anomalies discovered in the Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe maps and confirmed recently by the Planck satellite. The Cold Spot is one of the most significant of such anomalies, and the leading explanation of it posits a large void that imprints this extremely cold area via the linear Integrated Sachs-Wolfe (ISW) effect due to the decay of gravitational potentials over cosmic time, or via the Rees-Sciama (RS) effect due to late-time non-linear evolution. Despite several observational campaigns targeting the Cold Spot region, to date no suitably large void was found at higher redshifts $z > 0.3$. Here we report the detection of an $R =(192 pm 15) h^{-1}Mpc$ size supervoid of depth $delta = -0.13 pm 0.03$, and centred at redshift $z = 0.22$. This supervoid, possibly the largest ever found, is large enough to significantly affect the CMB via the non-linear RS effect, as shown in our Lemaitre-Tolman-Bondi framework. This discovery presents the first plausible explanation for any of the physical CMB anomalies, and raises the possibility that local large-scale structure could be responsible for other anomalies as well.
The alignment of the CMB Cold Spot and the Eridanus supervoid suggests a physical connection between these two relatively rare objects. We use galaxy cata-logues with photometric (2MPZ) and spectroscopic (6dF) redshift measurements, supplemented by low-redshift compilations of cosmic voids, in order to improve the 3D mapping of the matter density in the Eridanus constellation. We find evidence for a supervoid with a significant elongation in the line-of-sight, effectively spanning the total redshift range $z<0.3$. Our tomographic imaging reveals important substructure in the Eridanus supervoid, with a potential interpretation of a long, fully connected system of voids. We improve the analysis by extending the line-of-sight measurements into the antipodal direction that interestingly crosses the Northern Local Supervoid at the lowest redshifts. Then it intersects very rich superclusters like Hercules and Corona Borealis, in the region of the Coma and Sloan Great Walls, as a possible compensation for the large-scale matter deficit of Eridanus. We find that large-scale structure measurements are consistent with a central matter underdensity $delta_0 approx -0.25$, projected transverse radius $r_{0}^{perp}approx 195$ Mpc/h with an extra deepening in the centre, and line-of-sight radius $r_{0}^{parallel}approx500$ Mpc/h, i.e. an ellipsoidal supervoid. The expected integrated Sachs-Wolfe imprint of such an elongated supervoid is at the $Delta T_{rm ISW} approx -40 mu K$ level, thus inappropriate to accounting for the Cold Spot pattern in the CMB.
We use the WISE-2MASS infrared galaxy catalog matched with Pan-STARRS1 (PS1) galaxies to search for a supervoid in the direction of the Cosmic Microwave Background Cold Spot. Our imaging catalog has median redshift $zsimeq 0.14$, and we obtain photometric redshifts from PS1 optical colours to create a tomographic map of the galaxy distribution. The radial profile centred on the Cold Spot shows a large low density region, extending over 10s of degrees. Motivated by previous Cosmic Microwave Background results, we test for underdensities within two angular radii, $5^circ$, and $15^circ$. The counts in photometric redshift bins show significantly low densities at high detection significance, $gtrsim 5 sigma$ and $gtrsim 6 sigma$, respectively, for the two fiducial radii. The line-of-sight position of the deepest region of the void is $zsimeq 0.15-0.25$. Our data, combined with an earlier measurement by Granett et al. 2010, are consistent with a large $R_{rm void}=(220 pm 50) h^{-1}Mpc $ supervoid with $delta_{m} simeq -0.14 pm 0.04$ centered at $z=0.22pm0.03$. Such a supervoid, constituting at least a $simeq 3.3sigma$ fluctuation in a Gaussian distribution of the $Lambda CDM$ model, is a plausible cause for the Cold Spot.
Measurement of the acoustic peaks of the cosmic microwave background (CMB) temperature anisotropies has been instrumental in deciding the geometry and content of the universe. Acoustic peak positions vary in different parts of the sky due to statistical fluctuation. We present the statistics of the peak positions of small patches from ESA Planck data. We found that the peak positions have significantly high variance compared to the 100 CMB simulations with best-fit LambdaCDM model with lensing and Doppler boosting effects included. Examining individual patches, we found the one containing the mysterious Cold Spot, an area near the Eridanus constellation where the temperature is significantly lower than Gaussian theory predicts, displays large synchronous shift of peak positions towards smaller multipole numbers with significance lower than 1.11x 10^{-4}. The combination of large synchronous shifts in acoustic peaks and lower than usual temperature at the Cold Spot area results in a 4.73-sigma detection (significance p~ 1.11x 10^{-6}) against the LambdaCDM model. And it was already reported in Finelli et al. (2016) that in the WISE-2MASS galaxy catalog at z<0.3 the Cold Spot region is surrounded by surprisingly large underdense regions around 15 degs in radius, which are found to be in the same square patch. Thus we propose there is some extra localized unknown energy to stretch out the space in the transverse direction around the Cold Spot area to simultaneously account for the Cold Spot, excessive shift of the acoustic peaks, and the large underdense regions.
Log in to be able to interact and post comments
comments
Fetching comments
Sign in to be able to follow your search criteria
