Subscribe to the gold package and get unlimited access to Shamra Academy
Register a new userAre There Echoes From The Pre-Big Bang Universe? A Search for Low Variance Circles in the CMB Sky
113
0
0.0
(
0
)
Authors
Amir Hajian
Ask ChatGPT about the research
No Arabic abstract
The existence of concentric low variance circles in the CMB sky, generated by black-hole encounters in an aeon preceding our big bang, is a prediction of the Conformal Cyclic Cosmology. Detection of three families of such circles in WMAP data was recently reported by Gurzadyan & Penrose (2010). We reassess the statistical significance of those circles by comparing with Monte Carlo simulations of the CMB sky with realistic modeling of the anisotropic noise in WMAP data. We find that the circles are not anomalous and that all three groups are consistent at 3sigma level with a Gaussian CMB sky as predicted by inflationary cosmology model.
rate research
Read More
[Abridged] In a Universe with a detectable nontrivial spatial topology the last scattering surface contains pairs of matching circles with the same distribution of temperature fluctuations - the so-called circles-in-the-sky. Searches for nearly antipodal circles in maps of cosmic microwave background have so far been unsuccessful. This negative outcome along with recent theoretical results concerning the detectability of nearly flat compact topologies is sufficient to exclude a detectable nontrivial topology for most observers in very nearly flat positively and negatively curved Universes ($0<|Omega_{tot}-1| lesssim 10^{-5}$). Here we investigate the consequences of these searches for observable nontrivial topologies if the Universe turns out to be exactly flat ($Omega_{tot}=1$). We demonstrate that in this case the conclusions deduced from such searches can be radically different. We show that for all multiply-connected orientable flat manifolds it is possible to directly study the action of the holonomies in order to obtain a general upper bound on the angle that characterizes the deviation from antipodicity of pairs of matching circles associated with the shortest closed geodesic. This bound is valid for all observers and all possible values of the compactification length parameters. We also show that in a flat Universe there are observers for whom the circles-in-the-sky searches already undertaken are insufficient to exclude the possibility of a detectable nontrivial spatial topology. It is remarkable how such small variations in the spatial curvature of the Universe, which are effectively indistinguishable geometrically, can have such a drastic effect on the detectability of cosmic topology.
In this work we investigate the standard deviation of the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) temperature gradient field as a signature for a multiply connected nature of the Universe. CMB simulations of a spatially infinite universe model within the paradigm of the standard cosmological model present non-zero two-point correlations at any angular scale. This is in contradiction with the extreme suppression of correlations at scales above $60^{circ}$ in the observed CMB maps. Universe models with spatially multiply connected topology contain typically a discrete spectrum of the Laplacian with a specific wave-length cut-off and thus lead to a suppression of the correlations at large angular scales, as observed in the CMB (in general there can be also an additional continuous spectrum). Among the simplest examples are 3-dimensional tori which possess only a discrete spectrum. To date, the universe models with non-trivial topology such as the toroidal space are the only models that possess a two-point correlation function showing a similar behaviour as the one derived from the observed Planck CMB maps. In this work it is shown that the normalized standard deviation of the CMB temperature gradient field does hierarchically detect the change in size of the cubic 3-torus. It is also shown that the variance of the temperature gradient of the Planck maps is in slight anomaly with the median value of simulations within the standard cosmological model. All flat tori are globally homogeneous, but are globally anisotropic. However, this study also presents a test showing a level of homogeneity and isotropy of all the CMB map ensembles for the different torus sizes considered that are nearly at the same weak level of anisotropy revealed by the CMB in the standard cosmological model.
An important, and potentially detectable, signature of a non-trivial topology for the universe is the presence of so called circles-in-the-sky in the cosmic microwave background (CMB). Recent searches, confined to antipodal and nearly antipodal circles, have however failed to detect any. This outcome, coupled with recent theoretical results concerning the detectability of very nearly flat universes, is sufficient to exclude a detectable non-trivial cosmic topology for most observers in the inflationary limit ($0< |Omega_{tot}-1| lesssim 10^{-5}$). In a recent paper we have studied the consequences of these searches for circles if the Universe turns out to be exactly flat ($Omega_{tot} = 1 $) as is often assumed. More specifically, we have derived the maximum angles of deviation possible from antipodicity of pairs of matching circles associated with the shortest closed geodesic for all multiply-connected flat orientable $3$-manifolds. These upper bounds on the deviation from antipodicity demonstrate that in a flat universe for some classes of topology there remains a substantial fraction of observers for whom the deviation from antipodicity of the matching circles is considerably larger than zero, which implies that the searches for circles-in-the-sky undertaken so far are not enough to exclude the possibility of a detectable non-trivial flat topology. Here we briefly review these results and discuss their consequences in the search for circles-in-the-sky in a flat universes.
In a recent preprint (CCC-predicted low-variance circles in the CMB sky and LCDM), Gurzadyan and Penrose (2011) claim for the second time to find evidence for pre-Big Bang activity in the form of concentric circles of low variance in the WMAP data. The same claim was made in November 2010, but quickly shown to be false by three independent groups. The culprit was simply that Gurzadyan and Penroses simulations were based on an inappropriate power spectrum. In the most recent paper, they now claim that the significance is indeed low if the simulations are based on the realization-specific WMAP spectrum (ie., the one directly measured from the sky maps and affected by cosmic variance), but not if the simulations are based on a theoretical LCDM spectrum. In this respect, we note that the three independent reanalyses all based their simulations on the LCDM spectrum, not the observed WMAP spectrum, and this alone should suffice to show that the updated claims are also incorrect. In fact, it is evident from the plots shown in their new paper that the spectrum is still incorrect, although in a different way than in their first paper. Thus, Gurzadyan and Penroses new claims are just as wrong as those made in the first paper, and for the same reason: The simulations are not based on an appropriate power spectrum. Still, while this story is of little physical interest, it may have some important implications in terms of scienctific sociology: Looking back at the background papers leading up to the present series by Gurzadyan and Penrose, in particular one introducing the Kolmogorov statistic, we believe one can find evidence that a community based and open access referee process may be more efficient at rejecting incorrect results and claims than a traditional journal based approach.
Bimetric gravity is a ghost-free and observationally viable extension of general relativity, exhibiting both a massless and a massive graviton. The observed abundances of light elements can be used to constrain the expansion history of the Universe at the period of Big Bang nucleosynthesis. Applied to bimetric gravity, we readily obtain constraints on the theory parameters which are complementary to other observational probes. For example, the mixing angle between the two gravitons must satisfy $theta lesssim 18^circ$ in the graviton mass range $m_mathrm{FP} gtrsim 10^{-16} , mathrm{eV}/c^2$, representing a factor of two improvement compared with other cosmological probes.
Log in to be able to interact and post comments
comments
Fetching comments
Sign in to be able to follow your search criteria
