Measuring the brightness of classical noise dominated light at the shot noise limit?

A recent claim by Lieu et al that beam splitter intensity subtraction (or homodyne with one vacuum port) followed by high resolution sampling can lead to detection of brightness of thermal light at the shot noise limit is reexamined here. We confirm the calculation of Zmuidzinas that the claim of Lieu et al was falsified by an incorrect assumption about the correlations in thermal noise.