We propose a new approach to interactive full-image semantic segmentation which enables quickly collecting training data for new datasets with previously unseen semantic classes (A demo is available at https://youtu.be/yUk8D5gEX-o). We leverage a key observation: propagation from labeled to unlabeled pixels does not necessarily require class-specific knowledge, but can be done purely based on appearance similarity within an image. We build on this observation and propose an approach capable of jointly propagating pixel labels from multiple classes without having explicit class-specific appearance models. To enable long-range propagation, our approach first globally measures appearance similarity between labeled and unlabeled pixels across the entire image. Then it locally integrates per-pixel measurements which improves the accuracy at boundaries and removes noisy label switches in homogeneous regions. We also design an efficient manual annotation interface that extends the traditional polygon drawing tools with a suite of additional convenient features (and add automatic propagation to it). Experiments with human annotators on the COCO Panoptic Challenge dataset show that the combination of our better manual interface and our novel automatic propagation mechanism leads to reducing annotation time by more than factor of 2x compared to polygon drawing. We also test our method on the ADE-20k and Fashionista datasets without making any dataset-specific adaptation nor retraining our model, demonstrating that it can generalize to new datasets and visual classes.