Fascination with glassy states has persisted since Fisher introduced the vortex-glass as a new thermodynamic phase that is a true superconductor that lacks conventional long-range order. Though Fishers original model considered point disorder, it was later predicted that columnar defects (CDs) could also induce glassiness -- specifically, a Bose-glass phase. In YBa$_2$Cu$_3$O$_{7-x}$ (YBCO), glassy states can cause distinct behavior in the temperature ($T$) dependent rate of thermally activated vortex motion ($S$). The vortex-glass state produces a plateau in $S(T)$ whereas a Bose-glass can transition into a state hosting vortex excitations called double-kinks that can expand, creating a large peak in $S(T)$. Although glass phases have been well-studied in YBCO, few studies exist of other materials containing CDs that could contribute to distinguishing universal behavior. Here, we report on the effectiveness of CDs tilted ~30$deg$ from the c-axis in reducing $S$ in a NbSe$_2$ crystal. The magnetization is 5 times higher and $S$ is minimized when the field is parallel to the defects versus aligned with the c-axis. We see signatures of glassiness in both field orientations, but do not observe a peak in $S(T)$ nor a plateau at values observed in YBCO. We discuss the possibility that competing disorder induces a field-orientation-driven transition from a Bose-glass to an anisotropic glass involving both point and columnar disorder.
تحميل البحث