Subscribe to the gold package and get unlimited access to Shamra Academy
Register a new userHow not to obtain the redshift distribution from probabilistic redshift estimates: Under what conditions is it not inappropriate to estimate the redshift distribution N(z) by stacking photo-z PDFs?
182
0
0.0
(
0
)
Authors
Alex I. Malz
Ask ChatGPT about the research
No Arabic abstract
The scientific impact of current and upcoming photometric galaxy surveys is contingent on our ability to obtain redshift estimates for large numbers of faint galaxies. In the absence of spectroscopically confirmed redshifts, broad-band photometric redshift point estimates (photo-$z$s) have been superseded by photo-$z$ probability density functions (PDFs) that encapsulate their nontrivial uncertainties. Initial applications of photo-$z$ PDFs in weak gravitational lensing studies of cosmology have obtained the redshift distribution function $mathcal{N}(z)$ by employing computationally straightforward stacking methodologies that violate the laws of probability. In response, mathematically self-consistent models of varying complexity have been proposed in an effort to answer the question, What is the right way to obtain the redshift distribution function $mathcal{N}(z)$ from a catalog of photo-$z$ PDFs? This letter aims to motivate adoption of such principled methods by addressing the contrapositive of the more common presentation of such models, answering the question, Under what conditions do traditional stacking methods successfully recover the true redshift distribution function $mathcal{N}(z)$? By placing stacking in a rigorous mathematical environment, we identify two such conditions: those of perfectly informative data and perfectly informative prior information. Stacking has maintained its foothold in the astronomical community for so long because the conditions in question were only weakly violated in the past. These conditions, however, will be strongly violated by future galaxy surveys. We therefore conclude that stacking must be abandoned in favor of mathematically supported methods in order to advance observational cosmology.
rate research
Read More
We perform a quantitative morphological comparison between the hosts of Active Galactic Nuclei (AGN) and quiescent galaxies at intermediate redshifts (z~0.7). The imaging data are taken from the large HST/ACS mosaics of the GEMS and STAGES surveys. Our main aim is to test whether nuclear activity at this cosmic epoch is triggered by major mergers. Using images of quiescent galaxies and stars, we create synthetic AGN images to investigate the impact of an optical nucleus on the morphological analysis of AGN hosts. Galaxy morphologies are parameterized using the asymmetry index A, concentration index C, Gini coefficient G and M20 index. A sample of ~200 synthetic AGN is matched to 21 real AGN in terms of redshift, host brightness and host-to-nucleus ratio to ensure a reliable comparison between active and quiescent galaxies. The optical nuclei strongly affect the morphological parameters of the underlying host galaxy. Taking these effects into account, we find that the morphologies of the AGN hosts are clearly distinct from galaxies undergoing violent gravitational interactions. In fact, the host galaxies distributions in morphological descriptor space are more similar to undisturbed galaxies than major mergers. Intermediate-luminosity (Lx < 10^44 erg/s) AGN hosts at z~0.7 show morphologies similar to the general population of massive galaxies with significant bulges at the same redshifts. If major mergers are the driver of nuclear activity at this epoch, the signatures of gravitational interactions fade rapidly before the optical AGN phase starts, making them undetectable on single-orbit HST images, at least with usual morphological descriptors. This could be investigated in future synthetic observations created from numerical simulations of galaxy-galaxy interactions.
We study the reduced skewness, $S_{3,g}equivbar{xi}_{3,g}/bar{xi}_{2,g}^2$ of galaxy distribution at $z=0.5$ in two families of modfied gravity models: the Hu-Sawicki $f(R)$-gravity and normal-branch of Dvali-Gabadadze-Porrati (nDGP) models. We use a set of mock galaxy catalogues specifally designed to match CMASS spectroscopic galaxy sample. For the first time we investigate the third reduced moment of such galaxy distributions both in the redshift space. Our analysis confirms that the signal previously indicated only for dark matter halo catalogues persists also in realistic mock galaxy samples. This result offers a possibility to extract a potential modified gravity signal in $S_3$ from spectroscopic galaxy data without a need for a very precise and self-consistent RSD models constructed for each and every modified gravity scenario separately. We show that the relative deviations from $Lambda$CDM~ $S_{3,g}$ of various modified gravity models can vary from $7$ down to $sim 2-3%$ effects. Albeit, the effect looks small, we show that for considered models it can foster a $2-3sigma$ falsification. Finally we argue that galaxy sample of a significantly higher number density should provide even stronger constraints by limiting shot-noise effects affecting the $S_{3,g}$ estimates at small comoving separations.
We measure and analyse the redshift distribution N(z) of magnitude-selected samples using spectroscopic redshift measurement from the magnitude-selected VIMOS VLT Deep Survey (VVDS) with 17<iAB<24.75. We compute the N(z) and provide reference parametric fits for i band, J, H and Ks band magnitud limited samples. The N(z) of a sample with iAB<24 has a mean redshift z=0.92, with 8.2% of the galaxies with z>2. Down to iAB<24.75 the sample has a mean redshift z=1.15 and 17.1% of the galaxies are beyond z=2. The projected sky density is 2.07+/-0.12 gal/arcmin2 at 1.4<z<2.5 and KsAB<22.5, 1.72+/-0.15 gal/arcmin2 at 2.7<z<3.4 and 0.59+/-0.09 gal/arcmin2 at 3.4<z<4.5 brighter than iAB=24.75. Galaxies at z~3 identified from magnitude-selected samples are 1.5 to 3 times more numerous than when they are colour-colour selected. We demonstrate that colour-colour selected samples over 1.4<z<4.5 are strongly contaminated by galaxies at other redshifts. Semi-analytic models on the Millennium simulations under-predict the number of luminous star-forming galaxies at zsim1.8-2, as well as over-predict the number of low-luminosity galaxies at z<0.8. Our study provides comprehensive galaxy number counts N(z) from galaxies with spectroscopic redshifts over a large redshift domain 0<z<5, a solid basis for the measurement of volume-complete quantities. Magnitude-selected surveys identify a higher number of galaxies at z>2 than in colour-colour selected samples, and we use the magnitude-selected VVDS to emphasize the large uncertainties associated to other surveys using colour or colour-colour selected samples. Our results further demonstrate that semi-analytical models on dark matter simulations have yet to find the right balance of physical processes and time-scales to properly reproduce a fundamental galaxy population property like the observed N(z).
Evidence is presented that the galaxy distribution can be described as a fractal system in the redshift range of the FDF galaxy survey. The fractal dimension $D$ was derived using the FDF galaxy volume number densities in the spatially homogeneous standard cosmological model with $Omega_{m_0}=0.3$, $Omega_{Lambda_0}=0.7$ and $H_0=70 ; mbox{km} ; {mbox{s}}^{-1} ; {mbox{Mpc}}^{-1}$. The ratio between the differential and integral number densities $gamma$ and $gamma^ast$ obtained from the red and blue FDF galaxies provides a direct method to estimate $D$, implying that $gamma$ and $gamma^ast$ vary as power-laws with the cosmological distances. The luminosity distance $d_{scriptscriptstyle L}$, galaxy area distance $d_{scriptscriptstyle G}$ and redshift distance $d_z$ were plotted against their respective number densities to calculate $D$ by linear fitting. It was found that the FDF galaxy distribution is characterized by two single fractal dimensions at successive distance ranges. Two straight lines were fitted to the data, whose slopes change at $z approx 1.3$ or $z approx 1.9$ depending on the chosen cosmological distance. The average fractal dimension calculated using $gamma^ast$ changes from $langle D rangle=1.4^{scriptscriptstyle +0.7}_{scriptscriptstyle -0.6}$ to $langle D rangle=0.5^{scriptscriptstyle +1.2}_{scriptscriptstyle -0.4}$ for all galaxies, and $D$ decreases as $z$ increases. Small values of $D$ at high $z$ mean that in the past galaxies were distributed much more sparsely and the large-scale galaxy structure was then possibly dominated by voids. Results of Iribarrem et al. (2014, arXiv:1401.6572) indicating similar fractal features with $langle D rangle =0.6 pm 0.1$ in the far-infrared sources of the Herschel/PACS evolutionary probe (PEP) at $1.5 lesssim z lesssim 3.2$ are also mentioned.
The quasar ULAS J1120+0641 at redshift z=7.085 has a highly ionised near zone which is smaller than those around quasars of similar luminosity at z~6. The spectrum also exhibits evidence for a damping wing extending redward of the systemic Lya redshift. We use radiative transfer simulations in a cosmological context to investigate the implications for the ionisation state of the inhomogeneous IGM surrounding this quasar. Our simulations show that the transmission profile is consistent with an IGM in the vicinity of the quasar with a volume averaged HI fraction of f_HI>0.1 and that ULAS J1120+0641 has been bright for 10^6--10^7 yr. The observed spectrum is also consistent with smaller IGM neutral fractions, f_HI ~ 10^-3--10-4, if a damped Lya system in an otherwise highly ionised IGM lies within 5 proper Mpc of the quasar. This is, however, predicted to occur in only ~5 per cent of our simulated sight-lines for a bright phase of 10^6--10^7 yr. Unless ULAS J1120+0641 grows during a previous optically obscured phase, the low age inferred for the quasar adds to the theoretical challenge of forming a 2x10^9 M_sol black hole at this high redshift.
Log in to be able to interact and post comments
comments
Fetching comments
Sign in to be able to follow your search criteria
