We give a version in characteristic $p>0$ of Mumfords theorem characterizing a smooth complex germ of surface $(X,x)$ by the triviality of the topological fundamental group of $U=Xsetminus {x}$. This note relies on discussions the authors had during the Christmas break 2009/10 in Ivry. They have been written down by Hel`ene in the night when Eckart died, as a despaired sign of love.