Co-base superalloys are considered as promising high temperature materials besides the well-established Ni-base superalloys. However, Ni appears to be an indispensable alloying element also in Co-base superalloys. To address the influence of the base elements on the deformation behavior, high-temperature compressive creep experiments were performed on a single crystal alloy series that was designed to exhibit a varying Co/Ni ratio and a constant Al, W and Cr content. Creep tests were performed at 900 {deg}C and 250 MPa and the resulting microstructures and defect configurations were characterized via electron microscopy. The minimum creep rates differ by more than one order of magnitude with changing Co/Ni ratio. An intermediate CoNi-base alloy exhibits the overall highest creep strength. Several strengthening contributions like solid solution strengthening of the $gamma$ phase, effective diffusion coefficients or stacking fault energies were quantified. Precipitate shearing mechanisms differ significantly when the base element content is varied. While the Ni-rich superalloys exhibit SISF and SESF shearing, the Co-rich alloys develop extended APBs when the $gamma^prime$ phase is cut. This is mainly attributed to a difference in planar fault energies, caused by a changing segregation behavior. As result, it is assumed that the shearing resistivity and the occurring deformation mechanisms in the $gamma^prime$ phase are crucial for the creep properties of the investigated alloy series.