Quantum memory will be a key component in future quantum networks, and atomic frequency combs (AFCs) in rare-earth-doped crystals are one promising platform for realizing this technology. We theoretically and experimentally investigate the formation of AFCs in Pr3+:Y2SiO5, with an overall bandwidth of 120 MHz and tooth spacing ranging from 0.1 MHz to 20 MHz, showing agreement between our calculations and measurements. We observe that the echo efficiency depends crucially on the AFC tooth spacing. Our results suggest approaches to developing a high-efficiency AFC quantum memory.