The principle of multiple point criticality (PMPC), which allowed the prediction of the Higgs boson mass before its discovery, has so far been applied to radiatively generated vacua. If this principle is fundamental, following from some presently unknown underlying physics, the PMPC must apply to all vacua, including the multiple vacua of multi-scalar models dominated by tree-level terms. We first motivate this idea and then exemplify it by applying the PMPC to various realizations of singlet scalar dark matter models. We derive constraints on the dark matter properties from the requirement of degenerate vacua and show that some scalar dark matter models are ruled out by the PMPC, while in others the allowed parameters space is constrained.