Propellers are features in Saturns A ring associated with moonlets that open partial gaps. They exhibit non-Keplerian motion (Tiscareno 2010); the longitude residuals of the best-observed propeller, Bleriot, appear consistent with a sinusoid of period ~4 years. Pan and Chiang (2010) proposed that propeller moonlets librate in frog resonances with co-orbiting ring material. By analogy with the restricted three-body problem, they treated the co-orbital material as stationary in the rotating frame and neglected non-co-orbital material. Here we use simple numerical experiments to extend the frog model, including feedback due to the gaps motion, and drag associated with the Lindblad disk torques that cause Type I migration. Because the moonlet creates the gap, we expect the gap centroid to track the moonlet, but only after a time delay t_diff, the time for a ring particle to travel from conjunction with the moonlet to the end of the gap. We find that frog librations can persist only if t_diff exceeds the frog libration period P_lib, and if damping from Lindblad torques balances driving from co-orbital torques. If t_diff << P_lib, then the libration amplitude damps to zero. In the case of Bleriot, the frog resonance model can reproduce the observed libration period P_lib ~ 4 yr. However, our simple feedback prescription suggests that Bleriots t_diff ~ 0.01P_lib, which is inconsistent with the observed libration amplitude of 260 km. We urge more accurate treatments of feedback to test the assumptions of our toy models.
Download