Subscribe to the gold package and get unlimited access to Shamra Academy
Register a new userWhere is the residual entropy of a glass hiding?
130
0
0.0
(
0
)
Authors
P. D. Gujrati
Ask ChatGPT about the research
No Arabic abstract
We revisit the controversy, discussed recently by Goldstein in this journal[J. Chem. Phys. 128,154510 (2008)], whether the residual entropy is real or fictional. It is shown that the residual entropy loss conjecture (ELC) at the glass transition, which results in a discontinuous entropy violates many fundamental principles of classical thermodynamics, and also contradicts some experimental facts. Assuming, as is common in the field, that glasses are in internal equilibrium, we show that the continuity of enthalpy and volume at the glass transition require the continuity of the Gibbs free energy and the entropy, which contradicts ELC. It is then argued that ELC is founded on an incorrect understanding of what it means for a glass to be kinetically trapped in a basin and of the concept of probability and entropy. Once this misunderstanding is corrected in our approach by the proper identification of entropy as the ensemble entropy, which is in accordance with the principle of reproducibility (see Sect. II), it follows immediately that the residual entropy does not disappear in a kinetically frozen glassy state and all the violations of thermodynamics disappear. We show that the temporal definition of entropy over finite times does not make sense for glasses as it is not unique. There is no loss of ergodicity and causality, contrary to some recent claims.
rate research
Read More
A glass is a non-equilibrium thermodynamic state whose physical properties depend on time. Glass formation from the melt, as well as the inverse process of liquid structural recovery from the glass are non-equilibrium processes. A positive amount of entropy is produced during such irreversible processes. In this paper, we address the issue of the determination of entropy production during glass transition. Firstly, we theoretically determine the entropy production by means of the statistical model of a two-level system coupled to a master equation driving the time dependency of the occupancy probability of each state. Thermodynamic cycles of the type liquid-glass-liquid are considered in order to test the validity of the Clausius theorem. Secondly, we determine experimentally the production of entropy from differential scanning calorimetry experiments on the PolyVinylAcetate glass-former. Aging experiments are also considered. From the data treatments proposed here, we are able to determine the rate of production of entropy in each part of the experiments. Although being on the order of few % or less of the configurational entropy involved in the glass formation, the positive production of entropy is clearly determined. For all the thermodynamic cycles considered in these calorimetric experiments, the Clausius theorem is fulfilled.
We compare the macroscopic and the local plastic behavior of a model amorphous solid based on two radically different numerical descriptions. On the one hand, we simulate glass samples by atomistic simulations. On the other, we implement a mesoscale elasto-plastic model based on a solid-mechanics description. The latter is extended to consider the anisotropy of the yield surface via statistically distributed local and discrete weak planes on which shear transformations can be activated. To make the comparison as quantitative as possible, we consider the simple case of a quasistatically driven two-dimensional system in the stationary flow state and compare mechanical observables measured on both models over the same length scales. We show that the macroscale response, including its fluctuations, can be quantitatively recovered for a range of elasto-plastic mesoscale parameters. Using a newly developed method that makes it possible to probe the local yield stresses in atomistic simulations, we calibrate the local mechanical response of the elasto-plastic model at different coarse-graining scales. In this case, the calibration shows a qualitative agreement only for an optimized subset of mesoscale parameters and for sufficiently coarse probing length scales. This calibration allows us to establish a length scale for the mesoscopic elements that corresponds to an upper bound of the shear transformation size, a key physical parameter in elasto-plastic models. We find that certain properties naturally emerge from the elasto-plastic model. In particular, we show that the elasto-plastic model reproduces the Bauschinger effect, namely the plasticity-induced anisotropy in the stress-strain response. We discuss the successes and failures of our approach, the impact of different model ingredients and propose future research directions for quantitative multi-scale models of amorphous plasticity.
A Potts model and the Replica Exchange Wang-Landau algorithm are used to construct an energy landscape for a crystalline solid containing surfaces and grain boundaries. The energy landscape is applied to an equation of motion from the steepest-entropy-ascent quantum thermodynamic (SEAQT) framework to explore the kinetics of three distinct kinds of microstructural evolution: polycrystalline sintering, precipitate coarsening, and grain growth. The steepest entropy ascent postulate predicts unique kinetic paths for these non-equilibrium processes without needing any detailed information about the underlying physical mechanisms of the processes. A method is also proposed for associating the kinetic path in state space to a set of smoothly evolving microstructural descriptors. The SEAQT-predicted kinetics agree well with available experimental kinetics for ZrO2 sintering, Al3Li precipitate coarsening, and grain growth in nanocrystalline Pd. The computational cost associated with calculating the energy landscape needed by the approach is comparable to a Monte Carlo simulation. However, the subsequent kinetic calculations from the SEAQT equation of motion are quite modest and save considerable computational resources by obviating the need for averaging multiple kinetic Monte Carlo runs.
Entropy is a fundamental thermodynamic quantity that is a measure of the accessible microstates available to a system, with the stability of a system determined by the magnitude of the total entropy of the system. This is valid across truly mind boggling length scales - from nanoparticles to galaxies. However, quantitative measurements of entropy change using calorimetry are predominantly macroscopic, with direct atomic scale measurements being exceedingly rare. Here for the first time, we experimentally quantify the polar configurational entropy (in meV/K) using sub-r{a}ngstr{o}m resolution aberration corrected scanning transmission electron microscopy. This is performed in a single crystal of the prototypical ferroelectric $mathsf{LiNbO_3}$ through the quantification of the niobium and oxygen atom column deviations from their paraelectric positions. Significant excursions of the niobium - oxygen polar displacement away from its symmetry constrained direction is seen in single domain regions which increases in the proximity of domain walls. Combined with first principles theory plus mean field effective Hamiltonian methods, we demonstrate the variability in the polar order parameter, which is stabilized by an increase in the magnitude of the configurational entropy. This study presents a powerful tool to quantify entropy from atomic displacements and demonstrates its dominant role in local symmetry breaking at finite temperatures in classic, nominally Ising ferroelectrics.
We analyze the nature of the structural order established in liquid TIP4P water in the framework provided by the multi-particle correlation expansion of the statistical entropy. Different regimes are mapped onto the phase diagram of the model upon resolving the pair entropy into its translational and orientational components. These parameters are used to quantify the relative amounts of positional and angular order in a given thermodynamic state, thus allowing a structurally unbiased definition of low-density and high-density water. As a result, the structurally anomalous region within which both types of order are simultaneously disrupted by an increase of pressure at constant temperature is clearly identified through extensive molecular-dynamics simulations.
Log in to be able to interact and post comments
comments
Fetching comments
Sign in to be able to follow your search criteria
